3D Worship

I’m not going to pretend that I know what “worship” truly means. There seem to be many definitions out there, but I don’t think any of us ever fully “get it”. However, that doesn’t stop me from learning, exploring & wrestling with what worship looks like…for both my daily, personal life as well as the corporate gathering of the Church. At the end of the day, it’s all about amplifying God with our lives.
3D is all the craze right now; thank you, James Cameron! I’m sure one day 3D technology will be as accessible as an iPod, and it’s inevitable that a church somehow somewhere will implement 3D technology for worship. Maybe it will come via 3D glasses, Hologram, or some other technology invented just yesterday that we have yet to learn about. Who knows.
But as this new technology makes itself attractively accessible to us all, let’s make sure that WE are shaping the Church, instead of letting technology shape it. Let’s also remember that worship is for God…and not for us. So slippery a slope it is to lead worship…if we aren’t careful, we can start to “worship the worship” and even the leading of it. I struggle with this on a regular basis.
So if it’s really for God, what does 3-Dimensional worship look like through God’s Eyes? I stumbled across something that might help us better understand this. There are three dimensions to worship. Check this little graph out. (I’ll try not to go all “math” on ya.)

UP
“Up” is the vertical dimension of our worship. It’s a direct dialogue between God & His Church. It’s amplifying Him by declaring Who He is, what He’s done, and what He’s yet to do. There is revelation, and there is response. Corporate moments like this might include songs about God, prayer, & communion. This is the main dimension most of us think of when we talk about “worship.”
ACROSS
“Across” is the horizontal dimension of our worship. Yes, our worship is directed towards God, but there is an element of community & togetherness involved. These are those “one anothers” we hear about in the Scriptures. “Across” moments bring ourselves into the light, whether it’s through times of encouragement, edification, confession, forgiveness, celebration, healing, baptism or simply sharing someone’s story/testimony.
OUT
“Out” is the action part of our worship. This is where we put it all into motion & BE the Church. These are the moments of compassion, mercy, justice & mission. Sometimes it’s as simple as engaging in someone’s story with no agenda other than loving them or doing something for them and expecting nothing in return. It’s being the hands and feet of Christ. As it says in James, it’s going to the widows & the orphans…this is pleasing & acceptable worship to God. This is what makes our worship 3D! Without the “out” dimension, our worship is 2-dimensional and flat. Sure, we declare regularly Who God is and what He’s done, and we may get “community” like nobody’s business…but if we don’t do anything about it and love the world around us like Christ calls us to love, then we become stale, lukewarm & stagnant…and God will spit us out of His mouth eventually. Worship not in motion is a nasty, foul stench to God. We must be salt & light. Faith without deeds is dead.
Sometimes I wonder if our “out” is actually “in”. To be missional means to step out of your own context and into someone else’s, meeting them at their point of need. I’m not against inviting people to our churches & events, but if that’s the all-end of our efforts to “reach them”, I think we are missing it.
The great tension that I live with is trying to get all this with my own life, when I spend most of my days designing worship events & using new, cutting-edge technology. I see so much need out there…so many injustices…people who have never heard the name of Jesus… and yet I come home to help those of us (who have already heard) use motion backgrounds, triplewide screens & do worship “better”.
But I cannot discount the power of sacred times set aside for the Church to worship together…and I love to create environments where we can gather and meet with God. I see these times as exclamation points to our week of worship…and a launching pad for the next week. So I believe our content should be as 3D as possible! I’m all about leveraging technology & imagery to express in new, creative ways the things that are close to the heart of God.
The content of our gatherings usually falls into one of these dimensions. Even if there’s a moment that contains an aspect of each, there’s still a dimension that’s dominating the moment. I look at the context I’m leading in, and I do all I can do make sure the visual content I’m choosing aligns with the focus/dimension of the moment.
Think about your worship services…the songs, the visuals, everything. What moments could you categorize as “up”, “across” & “out”?
More to come.
———————————
Here is the continuation.
As someone who worked on 3D graphics technology in 2005 that was more advanced than that used in movie theaters today, I can appreciate all elements of this analogy. :)
[Translate]
God at play on June 3, 2010
thank you for this post, proctor! i think it is the start of an important conversation in the church…especially the church in america. i see the same disconnect that often exists between what we celebrate and focus on inside the walls of our church buildings and what we focus on outside of those walls. i have my moments where i see all of the injustice and areas where we are failing to be Christ’s hands and feet and i want to abandon all of the technology and visual worship because it seems so trivial. but as you said, we can’t discount the times set aside for the Church to gather together. these are important and God-pleasing. it gives us an opportunity to refresh and encourage one another so we can go out and pour love into the world. i think these are two areas that we will always have to hold in tension…and i think it can be a very sweet tension…and in fact probably and God-pleasing tension…one that He intended. on one hand He said “go into all the world” and on the other He said “do not give up meeting together”
i feel like most of the time the up and across dimensions come more naturally to our worship gatherings. but, it seems that the “out” dimension is one that we often miss in our visual content and worship gatherings in general. perhaps this is because it is missing from our lives as well?
[Translate]
Katie on June 3, 2010
Stephen, I thing your points are decent.. but I'm honestly waiting for a call to action. I think rockchurch version 3.0 is under discussion. How much of WCA showchurch should we keep? Can we be excellent and authentic? As we develop this new worship rhetoric, we should be careful to separate which of our critiques/suggestions we draw from scripture and which we draw from our own cultural preferences. As the "emerging generation" we have a value system (and I would even say worldview) that is different from the generation who created what we often criticize.
I imagine the 'authentic worship experiences' we crave might very well include 3D, but I would suppose it would be moving lights, or abstract art during worship. A holographic worship leader or pastor would be rejected.
Don't forget that the formula still works: new preacher starts using series based messages & programmed worship & rock n roll, drops churchy language and adds a welcome center : church grows and needs a new venue, then a new building, and within 10 years has more than tripled. It's still being implemented and working successfully across the country.
Then we come along and poke holes in some of the strategies.. it encourages consumerism among church attendees, it doesn't produce mature christians, the worship is plastic, etc.. the community is false, there isn't enough social gospel
We're in another generation.
What we're calling the church to needs to be fleshed out a little further. What about this 3D worship is different from how churches worship now? Are there churches achieving this 3D worship right now we should be emulating?
Kyle
[Translate]
kyle on June 3, 2010
Wow, Stephen. Love it. Love the metaphor of 3D used to communicate the important and multi-faceted "dimensions" we engage in our worship. I especially like your "out" b/c I've seen an older graph like this that leaves the "out" out. ;-)
The only thing I might add is another arrow-point aiming down on the "up" axis.
I personally used to be adamant about promoting worship as an "all for God" activity. Certainly this is a noble thought. But, I think it is incorrect. I now believe that worship isn't only for what God receives from us. In fact, there is a sense that worship is "all for us"!
What I mean is, God doesn't "need" our praise (though he certainly requires it). One way to think about it is that he has required us to worship him because he knows that this alone will form us into the humans he intended us to be. He has 'set it up' so that our vertical worship (sincerely and freely given) benefits US in exponential ways. We are transformed by the Spirit more and more into the image of Jesus through the time and sacrifice we spend giving ourselves back to God, whether in ritual worship or missional worship.
So, in my mind worship has a two-way vertical axis.
[Translate]
Eric Herron on June 3, 2010
Kyle, can you clarify a little more what you're talking about? It sounds like you think stephen's talking about literal 3d technology in worship. But that's not what he's saying at all.
[Translate]
Evan on June 4, 2010
There was a time when I removed corporate worship from my life. I thought I didn't need it but my faith never reached a weaker place. As far as the action part of worship, I'm pretty sure there is absolutely nothing to show from that period of my life.
However, on the flip side, the "Up" and "Across" of corporate worship this past year has made me more equipped and energized to be part of the "Out" than ever! When I reach out to someone else now it means my visual worship leaders are part of that act of worship, because I wouldn't be where I am – without God working through their actions every week.
[Translate]
Sherri on June 4, 2010
Kyle – As for the "formula working," you're right in that it brings in the numbers, but does it result in a body of believers who live their faith, whose lives are truly transformed by the Gospel? Do numbers equal disciples? If numbers are all we get from the formula, is that really success? I'm not so sure. Christ commanded us to make disciples, not just gather a crowd.
Maybe the idea that we can even have a "formula" is part of our problem. We aren't called to emulate each other but rather Christ.
Eric – I love the idea of a 4th dimension some place in the mix. My question is how and where exactly. I look at this diagram and at the middle of it is us or our acts of worship and their aim or direction which is 3 dimensional. The dimension of God transforming our hearts in worship, strengthening and encouraging us, is not of our doing or an aim or direction of our worship. Are we cheapening that by putting it in a diagram that otherwise focuses on what we're doing in worship or how we're worshiping? I don't have an answer…just thinking out loud.
[Translate]
Katie on June 4, 2010
I've hesitated on replying to any of these comments, and I'm glad i have thus far… really great dialogue guys. I'm excited that so many of you are connecting to this, or at least stirred up enough to write somethings on your heart. Keep it coming!
Kyle, I understand where you are coming from, as we've eaten many a Baja Burrito together & have jumped in the deep-end of philosophy, art & the future direction of Church. We need to do that again sometime. Maybe this will be good fodder for our next hang time.
I think some of the things you bring up are good but for a different discussion, and I'm going to stick to the point of this discussion. Bottom-line, I don't believe "3D worship" is a formula or any new "method"…it's simply the DNA structure of what biblical worship looks like. How churches express their worship on a Sunday morning could & should look a million different ways. Ultimately, the overall "why" is the same…the "how" & "what" look different. Formulas focus on the "how" & "what" & are easy to emulate…but again, whether that's right or wrong or neither is another conversation. This post & graph were never intended to be a "formula" but rather to unveil what i believe is the biblical DNA of worship. And this should apply to ALL churches & believers.
Eric – i love that you bring this up, and I actually thought about this as I drew the graph and wrote this post. But the PERSPECTIVE on this post on "3D Worship" is, i guess, how God RECEIVES worship. My priority focus when leading worship ( choosing content, curating a context, VJ-ing, etc ) is that it is pleasing to God…thinking about how He receives it…. i don't focus as much on the people and if it's a pleasing worship experience for them. Yes, there's balance, i know.
I think if we added an arrow going down, then I'd add arrows in opposite directions for every dimension.
Worship as a whole is UP AND DOWN…that's what true dialogue is.
Worship is also ACROSS both ways…we encourage others, and in turn we are encouraged by doing so (either internally or it results in encouragement back in words or action from those we encouraged).
And when we step OUT and serve others, we are blessed and poured into more than we could imagine. Mocha Club's campaign sums it up the best: "I need Africa more than Africa needs me." We have MUCH to receive from the lost, broken & abandoned…. it's a two way street. I think it applies to each dimension. And i think our context & content in times of worship should reflect this.
But again, the focus for this post is on God's perspective when receiving worship. The direction of each arrow is to help us navigate our worship….our response to Him. He initiates…He gives a revelation (& He does so in each dimension.) He receives worship when we talk, pray, sing, etc to Him directly… when we love each other & live well in community… and when we step out and love on the least of these. He is worshiped!
[Translate]
proctor on June 4, 2010