A Neo-Liturgical Convergence
At the beginning of the year, I wrote a post called “A New Liturgy.” It was both a condensed version of my own journey of discovering the beauty and mystery of liturgical worship, as well as a review of Aaron Niequist’s new musical experiment. According to Google Analytics, it was the top post of this blog’s year. Interesting.
Since writing that post, I’ve learned so much more about why the Liturgy draws me into a deeper communion with Jesus and the mystery of the Trinity that is to be enjoyed and shared with others! I’d love to share all that, but honestly, it’s still hard to put into words. Perhaps words are simply inadequate, and it is just better experienced than talked about. Still, here is an fascinating revelation I saw the other day.
Tim Keller’s “Center Church”
I’ve been skimming through Tim Keller’s new textbook on church culture. Here are a few of his general observations on today’s worship culture that stuck out at me.
• Classical music and liturgy appeal to the educated. “High” cultural forms are those that, by definition, require training to appreciate.
• Contemporary praise/worship approaches are far more likely to bring together a diversity of racial groups.
• Young professional Anglos, especially of the more artistic bent, are highly attracted to the convergence of liturgical/historical with eclectic musical forms.
• Baby boomer families are highly attracted to seeker-sensitve worship and the more ahistorical, sentimental Christian contemporary songs.
Check out this graph by Keller:
(graph from Tim Keller’s “Center Church”)
Interesting, huh? Yeah, I thought so, too.
I realize that not every church is going to fit neatly into one category, but still, Keller pretty much nails it, in my opinion. It really gives us a big picture perspective on the various expressions and diversity of today’s Church. If you look closely, you can see how Christ is manifesting Himself to us in so many ways! He meets us in the physical…in our minds…emotions…songs…stories…art…in our practical everyday living…and even in our mystical imaginations!
For our visual worship tribe, I think all of this can greatly inform us on how we choose our visuals, just like our music. After all, we talk a lot about “knowing your people.” So much to unpack here! Wow.
Keller goes on to write:
“As you design your worship, you cannot naively assume you are ‘just being biblical’ about many things that are actually cultural and personal preferences. Think of who is in your community and skew your worship service toward them in all the places where your biblical theology and historic tradition leave you freedom.”
This statement definitely grounds me, as I can easily let my preferences and own cultural worldview dictate what is better, stronger and more “right,” especially for everyone else. And that’s not good for anyone. However…
…the third column interests me greatly!!! The ancient approach of musically and visually designing a worship service as a story … this puts wind in my sails!
These days, I’m talking to more and more worship leaders who are interested in not only the music of our worship, but also the form of our services & liturgies. And I bet more of us are more “mystical” than we care to admit, too! Our culture is evolving, so if you want a heads-up on what’s “coming next” in the world of worship (at least for some of us), then pay close attention to the third column. ;-)
Perhaps we are in the midst of a “Liturgical Reformation” of sorts. And if so, it’s going to have a soundtrack.
(continued here: “A Neo-Liturgical Soundtrack”)
__________________________________________________
read more about today’s church culture in Tim Keller’s “Center Church.”





The form is the message! Woot!
Paul G on October 24, 2012
McLuhan, baby.
stephen proctor on October 24, 2012
As a second generation (1989) leader of the neo-liturgists I can tell you that the reformation has been emerging since the 70′s (first generation) and we are glad that those in this day are also continuing on the journey.
Michael welchert on October 24, 2012
It's so exciting that this has been going on for some time in other areas of the Church. The torch is definitely being passed. If it weren't for my mentors (those who have gone before me), I would have no clue what's going on. =)
stephen proctor on October 24, 2012
First generation leaders… Webber, Gilquist, Oden…the Chicago Call
Michael welchert on October 24, 2012
Thanks Procter. I'm so into this right now at my church with the traditional service that I lead and inspired and affirmed of the need in our church for a deeper experience in worship.
Alexis
Alexis on October 24, 2012
There's so much room for growth for all of us. All of this has to be worked out in the local church, especially when one community has multiple generations and cultures who connect with God in different ways. I wonder if the liturgical convergence of form, word, music & visuals has something for all of us…not just the young Anglo hipsters. =)
stephen proctor on October 24, 2012
I'm really keen to read Keller's book (not least because the cover shot is literally one block south of the church we were a part of London). It's really helpful to think through what cultural assumptions drive our stylistic approach – and to recognise that our own preferences may need challenging, but also give way to others.
We are finding it very interesting here in Germany – having been part of low-Anglican churches in the UK & Australia – because the free churches can be very reactionary to nominal state-churchism, and so things liturgical can often often be the proverbial baby with the bathwater. It's a good challenge to think about how one might bring those elements or frameworks in to a much more intentionally ahistorical assumption.
AndrewF on October 30, 2012